MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/30/2024 9:45pm
... as it has so far. it will be an advantage, but we just don't know how much. but you are correct. i think when put on its own, a clear majority of americans want basic abortion rights. and women too. it's a game changer. tim, thank you for being here. frank, it's nice to see you. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/30/2024 9:41pm
... regulations, and articles, even those found in the constitution, trump responded by deny he said it. did he say it, tim? he said it. he repeatedly has said it ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/30/2024 9:35pm
... 2016. they did find him entertaining. i am your retribution is not an entertaining message, even for his most devoted supporters. thank you for standing outside for us. it was great to get to talk to you. thank you. tim and frank stick around. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/30/2024 9:30pm
... i really do. tim, you led the investigation of a lot of of the things that made this issue of democracy meaningful for people. people saw what it meant when you lis theed responses from his ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/30/2024 9:26pm
... alarming are risk. it could bring the end of our democracy, says presidential historian douglas brinkley, and the birth of a new kind of authoritarian presidential order. joining our coverage, tim haity is back with us and with me at ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/30/2024 1:40pm
... me that. meanwhile just the hatred and venom inside of these churches is shocking. tim alberta told his story of being at his dad's funeral and the receiving line coming in and people attacking him for ...
MSNBC: The 11th Hour With Stephanie Ruhle
4/30/2024 3:24am
... contributor brian tyler cowen and tim miller, host of the bulwark podcast and former communications director for republican jim wish. these polling numbers on the economy are not a surprise. the pollsters are saying how do you feel? people don't feel great because life is extensive, your food is ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/29/2024 11:39pm
... or whatever he's calling himself now adds his name to the long list of republicans who went from challenging or opposing to trump to publicly degrading themselves on his behalf, joining the likes of lindsey graham, ted cruz, and tim scott. joining me is matthew dowd, ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:34pm
... there are a lot of dog lovers out there. donald trump may not be one of them, tim, but he hasn't said anything that i know of about noem yet. we want to wait to see how it shakes out. ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:33pm
... about it, so, tim, i want to go back to kristi noem for a second. when i was at the white house correspondents dinner this weekend, everybody was talking about this. and the lincoln project, no surprise, seized on it with a ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:32pm
... one could argue tim scott's presidential campaign never really got off the ground but the week he tried to get it off the ground, he couldn't. it took him six or seven different tries to answer where was he on a federal abortion ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:32pm
... thought, that, for instance, tim scott can help with suburban folks, at least the thinking goes. but even trump, and we have heard this and he thinks that scott's position on abortion, and frankly his inability to handle it. ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:31pm
... like noam in south dakota, these are not battle ground states, might he want someone to come from a place where they could help him, tim scott, marco rubio. i certainly think that is what some in trump world have ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/29/2024 6:30pm
... todd and tim miller, also an msnbc political analyst. oh, chuck, kristi noem is defending herself, and this is what she wrote on x, the fact is south dakota law states that dogs who attack and kill livestock can be put down. ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/29/2024 8:43am
... sentenced to death and killed, and yet in israel they'd have the same rights as any other citizen and yet they're aligning themselves with palestinians. we have about 30 seconds left. the national guard should potentially be called in. senator tim kaine said that ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/29/2024 8:32am
... there are also things we have in common and i found that in my virginia nature triathlon. it is a pretty profound message. it is a good read. senator tim kaine, thank you so much for joining us for your insights this morning. we really appreciate it. you bet. thanks, kristen. when we come back, as ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/29/2024 8:24am
... spread. more than 200 protesters were arrested at campuses across the country saturday. usc has canceled its main commencement ceremony. joining me now is democratic senator tim kaine of virginia, ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/29/2024 8:24am
... thank you. when we come back, student protests over the war in gaza spread across the country. will it impact president biden's re-election campaign? democratic senator tim kaine of virginia joins me next. welcome back. colleges across the country are grappling with growing tensions over the war in ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/29/2024 8:02am
... senator tim kaine of virginia. and barrier breaker. civil rights icon ruby bridges joins me for our meet the moment conversation. i was thrust into the middle of a situation that no 6-year-old should be put in. joining me for insight and ...
MSNBC: PoliticsNation
4/28/2024 9:38pm
... bias and at the same time, they should be treating the next president like any other person even more so because we have told presidents to higher standards. i think pulling like you just showed, it demonstrates some of the frame that comes from trump's assault on democracy. all right, anthony and ...
MSNBC: PoliticsNation
4/28/2024 9:31pm
... to court on tuesday as his hush money trial enters the third week. joining me now is tim o'brien, msnbc political analyst and anthony, former white house ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/28/2024 5:15pm
... situation where repeated violations have occurred. the d.a.s office has asked for a second show cause order. i think tim is dead on the money here. either the judge and forces the gag order or trump continues to come home at 12:30 every night. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/27/2024 5:17pm
... this is a very good word. that's all the segments we talked about last segment. tim, he said that second contempt hearing, he is accused of violating the gag order more than a dozen times. then he even says, pecker is a ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/27/2024 5:16pm
... praise and defense strategy. perry and tim are back with you. let's talk about what trump is known for. deny, deny, deny, delay, delay. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/27/2024 5:11pm
... the guards pushed him back. she had a broad smile and she was ushered out. it was plain that she is so friendly that the prosecutor said, we better stay away from this. just to a quick point to what tim had to say, credibility matters. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/27/2024 5:07pm
... not relying on them. also making it clear this is about the campaign, nothing else. so tim, pecker agreed the ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/27/2024 5:04pm
... thank you very much for that. also, our good friend timothy havey, former prosecutor and -- for the january 6th select committee. welcome to you, tim. ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:47pm
... she puts people in private meetings. she is that paper trail, the personification, absolutely. the last part of what tim said, what's the one question, and he gave us three, one was about how many women maybe that there was communication about, how many did, you know, they want to keep quiet, but ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:46pm
... had in your possession discuss impact on his process as a presidential candidate in 2016. tim o'brien, your knowledge of donald trump is vast. and so useful to today. thank you so much for taking the time to talk to us. i'm going to go back to you ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:46pm
... trump organization. she's a very material witness, and i imagine there's very hard documentation behind any fact pattern, they may allege when they question her. i know you have to go, tim, i have to ask the last question. ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:45pm
... of, you know, name recognition because people would actually call trump tower looking for her. tim o'brien, what can you tell us about rhona graff? there's much more here than simply rhona graff was in the inner circle with donald trump. ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:40pm
... widely, everything that he had built for such a long time. i asked this question of vaughn hillyard earlier, but what is it about donald trump, as someone who has studied him, written about him for so long, tim, that ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:39pm
... fulton county, and federal charges in washington, d.c. related to attempts to overturn the 2020 election, chris. tim, rudy giuliani is maybe, i don't know, evidence number one in people who have been loyal. i got to tell you, i mean for ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:36pm
... over. i understand what you're saying, tim. on the other hand, i think if there's a surprise for some people in this so far with david pecker it happened just a little bit earlier today, right? because he's being i don't want to say hammered but he's being ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/26/2024 6:34pm
... political analyst, tim o'brien who wrote the book on trump, 'trump nation the art of being the donald' during the height of his celebrity in 2005. tristan snell and jeremy soland are back with me. tim, i wonder what that anecdote ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/25/2024 9:05am
... what he did for me. seemed to be in direct violation of the order as it is written. i think it's problematic for him especially while the judge is currently sitting and trying to decide the issue. tim, you're no longer on the ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/25/2024 9:05am
... he criticized michael cohen, and now one of trump's former attorneys is weighing in on those remarks. here's what trump said followed by new comments from his former lawyer, tim parlator. michael cohen is a convicted ...
MSNBC: The 11th Hour With Stephanie Ruhle
4/25/2024 6:53am
... for all of us. these people do not forget and bar has done the one thing even after he is now engaging in the tim scott -like ritual humiliation, which is he betrayed trump and in these kinds of movements, the trail is the ultimate sin. he will never forgive bar. that's so embarrassing. ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:31am
... their job. another day, another indictment. tim, thank you very much for joiningous discussion. andrew, stay with us for our discussion of the supreme court. tomorrow the supreme court will hear arguments on donald trump's claim that he has absolute criminal immunity for ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:30am
... bolts effort. tim sounds like an arizona grand jury. lawrence, that's america. that is how our system works. it is regular people summoned for grand jury service. they go to work every day. and they get this thing in the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:24am
... 14th, 2020. falsely claiming to be the duly elected and qualified electors for president and vice president of the united states from the state of arizona. former federal prosecutors tim and andrew are back with us. and tim, the attorney general ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:19am
... these cases. so these people are going to be going to trial in arizona. what tim is saying so people understand this is no joke. these charges prove this is what you see in like petty ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:15am
... court that could then allow these electors to be used. the attorney general's indictment says absolutely not. they always planned to try to use these electors on january 6th no matter what happened in court. and tim, there is a last line ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:14am
... versus, you need to start finding religion and join team america. it is possible that is the main reason you don't see his name here. as tim knows very well from investigating this deeply, he was in the thick of things. ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:13am
... appear and presumably, it is because he has counsel who has said look, if you do not want to be as tim and i used to say on the other side of a v, united states versus or arizona ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:12am
... and those names are actually the three of the people charged. tim, did you learn anything in this indictment? that you hadn't already had a pretty clear sense of in the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 5:10am
... tim and his colleagues put together a vast amount of proof. it was added onto by jack smith which showed this scheme was happening from the campaign down to the states. ...
MSNBC: The 11th Hour With Stephanie Ruhle
4/25/2024 3:53am
... in the tim scott like ritual of humiliation. which is he betrayed donald trump. in these movements, betrayal is the ultimate sin. he will never forgive barr. it is so embarrassing. oh god. ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:31am
... another day, another indictment. tim heaphy, thank you very much for joining our discussion. andrewandrew weissmann, please stay with us. tomorrow donald trump will hear arguments on his supreme court ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:30am
... prosecutors seemed more focused on nuts and bolts efforts to substantiate discreet pieces of evidence. tim, it sounds like an arizona grand jury. lawrence, that's america. that's how our system works. ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:25am
... tim heaphy and andrew weissmann are back with us. the attorney general also said tonight the investigation is ongoing. they are still working on the investigation, but when you consider the status of donald trump in this indictment as ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:18am
... doesn't matter because you cannot have a federal pardon of these cases. so these people are going to be going to trial in arizona on these charges. just to be clear, what tim is saying so people understand ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:14am
... use these electors on january 6th no matter what happened in court. tim, there's a last line that appears at the end of the charge against every elector beginning with kelli ward and ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:13am
... in this case arizona versus, you need to start finding religion and join team america. so it's possible that that is the main reason that you don't see his name here because otherwise as tim knows very well from having investigated this deeply, he was in the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:11am
... says, 'rudy, boris, and jenna,' and those names are actually three of the people who are charged or appear to be charged. so those are my quick takes of the charges here. tim, did you learn anything ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/25/2024 2:10am
... a couple things. one, it's very similar to what we have seen in other states where there have been charges in georgia and michigan where there was a top down scheme. what i mean by that is that tim ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:39pm
... or only got room for 13 people. your job as a prosecutor is to hold people accountable for criminal conduct and that appears to be what's happening in arizona tonight. tim heaphy, give us contours of this new set of names. you have boris epstein. ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:38pm
... epstein. to me it's a vindication in my mind, at least, of what she did in georgia. well, i think it suggests that fani willis was the immaculate career prosecutor we know her to be. tim will tell you this, too. when you're a prosecutor, ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:37pm
... call 833.leaf.filter today or visit leaffilter.com. back now with the breaking news, the indictments in the arizona fake elector scheme. we're back with vaughn hillyard and tim heaphy. ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:32pm
... prosecutor sitting right here is so great to have. thank you very much, my friend. i appreciate you. we are keeping tim and vaughn. they aren't going anywhere. we have so much more on this. i'm going to give bernie back his phone while we take this very quick commercial break. we'll be right back. ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:30pm
... he becomes president. if chesebro -- there's a reason he has not been indictmented. has to be that he's cooperating. and so that is another potential witness for you in the federal case if it ever goes. tim heaphy, if you're fani ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:27pm
... arizona? there certainly is with rudy giuliani and other lawyers, joy, my guess is some of those other redacted names could be john eastman -- tim heaphy, it's as if you're reading my mind. i have a 'washington post' story in front of me. you're very wise. ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:25pm
... yes, it does. tim heap hy is unindicted coconspirator -- redacted defendant, sorry. redacted defendant. i'm updating even as we speak. one of the redacted defendants ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:14pm
... indicted on state charges stemming from this alleged scheme to send to washington, d.c. ultimately a different slate of electors to be counted on january 6th of 2021. don't go anywhere, vaughn. andrew weissmann, first your reaction. i also want to get tim heaphy's ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:09pm
... for what happened on january 6th, i'll start with you, tim, would he have been a defendant in a case were he not the president, like long before now? absolutely. look, the justice department started with the blue collar cases, the people that were at ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/24/2024 11:09pm
... cause of the riot, as the committee found and as the special counsel will have the burden to prove in the trial. right. and tim, if you were -- i'll ask both of you. if donald trump were not president of the united states, given the fact that people are spending 20 plus years in prison ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:42pm
... about the long-term viability of the american security umbrella. justifiably, right. tim miller, thank you for spending time with us today. katty sticks around a little bit longer. after the break, the world is watching as an american ex-president and a presumptive ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:39pm
... consensus that includes some republicans, i think he'll be successful again like he was in 2020. tim, i do usually have a big lengthy windup question, but i just wanted to hear from you. sorry if i threw you. i take your point. it's something i observed about ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:37pm
... killed it, even though it had lots of stuff they wanted, to make donald trump happy. wow. tim and katty are back. tim? that's something. we got to give joe biden a lot of credit. i was waiting for question. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:25pm
... freedom for all, minnie tim raju was here. she was outside the supreme court today speaking to a crowd about reproductive rights and freedom. with me at the table, former obama white house policy director, msnbc medical ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:17pm
... things people like you say on this program. andrew weissman, thank you for being so generous with your time, doing double duty for all of us. tim will be back later in the broadcast. katty doesn't go anywhere. when we come back, abortion rights are before the united states supreme court today on a ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:12pm
... now, sitting here. it's incredible. tim miller, who is obviously by design, here is conservative's conservative judge michael ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/24/2024 9:06pm
... bbc studios katty kay is here. joining us rnc spam, host of the bulwark podcast tim miller is here. back with me at the table former official at the department of justice, msnbc analyst the indispensable andrew weissman is ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/22/2024 11:44pm
... anticipating his testimony today. it gauze cut short, but i'll be there tomorrow to watch it. it could be unraveling trump. we shall see. tim o'brien, thank you very much. coming up, columbia university switched to remote learning today as student protests over the war in gaza enter a sixth day and ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/22/2024 11:39pm
... and incoherently untethered to reality, at least when he's awake. joining me now is tim o'brien, msnbc political analyst. i'm glad you're here, tim, because it does seem to me this is the shrinking of donald trump. his legend is kind of hard to keep up with when jurors are ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/22/2024 11:33pm
... email? make it make sense. thank you all very much. up next on 'the reidout,' the tim o'brien joins me on how this trial is the reality show trump never, ever wanted. stay with us. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:57pm
... it now. barbara mcquade, thank you for spending time with her husband tim o'brien and charlie sykes thank you for spending the hour with us pretty coming up, our coverage of the trump trial continues. i will be back in place filling in for my friend after a quick break. stay with us. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:57pm
... both sanctions will escalate up to and including jail. or even up to 30 days. holding that lever over trump's head is a valuable lever. even if this is something that donald trump wants, then maybe he will get it. all i can think about is tim ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:55pm
... if tens of millions of people do not believe it anymore, this is a low to our constitutional order. the question that i have and i would defer to tim on all of this be. i do not know donald trump psychology. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:52pm
... legal analyst barbara mclagan rated tim and charlie are still with us. trump is not going to change, ever, full stop. what does everyone else do? ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:47pm
... i agree with you. claire mccaskill, thank you my friend for spending time with us. tim and charlie stick around a little bit longer. coming up next for us, the manhattan d.a. says donald trump has violated his gag order at least seven times since last monday. and that does not even include his ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:35pm
... has more to do with us than them. thank you for being here and starting us off. tim, charlie, and claire stick around. after the break a warning, a dire, direct and blunt warning from liz cheney. time is ticking. if we want to hold trump accountable for the deadly insurrection. that's next. at's ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:24pm
... .and through meaningful partnerships with families, they become centers of their communities. real solutions for kids and communities at aft.org. we are back on this day of special coverage. tim, anna, charlie, and claire are back. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:17pm
... but it had tremendous implications for this. and i know that tim remembers this. it's burned into our consciousness at the time. and i'm hoping that as people watch this they don't get drawn too much into the trivia of, you ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 9:05pm
... opinion and msnbc political analyst tim o'brian's here. and lawfare legal fellow and courts correspondent anna bower is here. you were both down at the courthouse today. also joining us msnbc contributor and columnist charlie sykes is back. and former senator and co-host of msnbc's 'how to win 2024' ...
MSNBC: Meet the Press
4/22/2024 8:02am
... we have lived through hard tim i feel so positive about what history can teach us. we have lived through hard times before. joining me for insight and correspondent andrea mitchell, ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 6:38pm
... those who are part of the chinese communist party. i've got to get in one more question on this. you are out with this new book, walk, ride, paddle, life outside. i'm about to defy the good manners that my parents taught me about a 40 of the good respective calling you senator or governor or mayor, ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 6:31pm
... special sauce and the pasta. thank you so much for that one. joined me now, democratic senator from virginia, tim kaine. he is the author of a terrific new book, walk, ride, paddle, a life outside. senator, we are going to get to tiktok, the book as well. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 6:23pm
... senator tim kaine joins me next on whether he expects the senate to vote to potentially ban one of the most popular apps on social media. . one pill a day, 24 hours, zero heartburn. there's nothing better than a subway series footlong. except when you add a new footlong sidekick. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 6:08pm
... done in this place. yes, okay. julie from the capital. thank you, my friend. stomach coming up later, tim kaine, he is going to join me with his reaction to the ford -- foreign aid funding and his prediction for how the bills ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 5:57pm
... not only do i admire you, but so do many viewers. thank you, my friend. we will see you soon. this is one of the lesser highlighted subjects. senator tim kaine will join me ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/21/2024 5:06pm
... they can do it as soon as tuesday. there's overwhelming bipartisan support to get this through and the president said he would sign it as soon as congress approves. coming up, i will get reaction from senator tim kaine, ...
MSNBC: PoliticsNation
4/20/2024 9:25pm
... south carolina senator tim scott's failed campaign barely registered in the polls, but it seems he is still chasing the national spotlight. the senators latest venture is a web video series called ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/20/2024 7:44pm
... into this moment. joining the not is tim o'brien, msnbc political and is an senior executive editor of bloomberg opinion. he is also the author of the book, trump nation: the art of being the donald. welcome. it is always good to talk with you about this. ...
MSNBC: Velshi
4/20/2024 3:09pm
... as a religious figure is really enough to even win the electoral college. the argument that tim snyder makes frul yale is that he doesn't need it to be enough. he needs it to be close. ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/20/2024 8:53am
... what he did. reporter: dan said that he gave him a box to hold on to t he had no idea there was a gun inside, let alone that his brother just murdered two people. tim pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact and was sentenced to three years of ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/20/2024 8:28am
... that. i don't know how to describe it. reporter: he was charged with two counts of first-degree murder. dan's older brother tim, along with tim's girlfriend was also arrested and charged with ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/20/2024 8:15am
... some evidence? yes. oh, god. oh, god. it is the voice of a man in a trap. this is ridiculous and i have to tell detectives the truth. tim didn't speak up. reporter: only to me so far ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/20/2024 8:15am
... something. reporter: with that information, dan's mood suddenly changed. i'm doomed. what? tim said that? do you know that tim has ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/20/2024 8:14am
... him and let him no before they catch me on this recording device because it looks like i'm not trying to tell him right away. tim said that he has evidence or he knew where he was or ...