MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
5/2/2024 5:34am
... state of wisconsin. has to spread the word that one candidate joe biden is on the side of workers and one candidate donald trump will screw them over. and we will leave it there. ben, thank you very much for ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
5/2/2024 2:34am
... candidate, donald trump, is going to screw them over like he screwed over workers who worked for him for decades. with that we will leave it there. ben wikler, thank you very much. coming up, donald trump raised the conservative supreme court justices by name on the ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/29/2024 10:20am
... ted cruz, that his father had helped kill jfk. ben carson destroyed somebody's life by leaving a sponge in their brain. hillary clinton saying back in 2016 she has six months to live, ...
MSNBC: The Weekend
4/27/2024 1:05pm
... like ben carson or ted cruz and send the nugget over and the national enquirer would, according to david pecker, quote unquote, embellish it and ride a negative story about it. it was story after story about like headlight after headline ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/27/2024 5:28am
... ruth ben-ghiat, history professor at new york university and the author of 'strongman, from mussolini to the president.' coming up, a look at how big and real if a collectors plot was in trump's effort to overturn the 2020 election. going to arizona. we will discuss that with ryan j riley, after ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/27/2024 5:22am
... normalizing extreme ideas and involves giving them a respected platform. joining us now is ruth ben- ghiat, history professor at new york university and author of 'strongman, was leaning to ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/27/2024 2:28am
... with, for example, putin's russia or north korea. ruth, thank you. i appreciate you being with us tonight. ruth ben-ghiat is a history professor at new york university and author of strongmen, from mussolini to the present. coming up we got a look at the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/27/2024 2:22am
... being taken seriously and debated is a big victory in the information war that maga and allies wage. authoritarian specialize in normalizing extreme ideas and this involves giving them a respected platform. joining us now is ruth ben- ...
MSNBC: All In With Chris Hayes
4/27/2024 0:35am
... ben franklin quote, which he keeps throwing out there every time, when there is an enormous corpus of writing from folks who were actually at the constitutional convention, who were at the state convention saying obviously the president is not immune. all right. i pulled that from the great ...
MSNBC: All In With Chris Hayes
4/27/2024 0:00am
... more and share are being honored at the rock and roll hall of fame. they once a week. michelangelo signorile, ben collins, congratulations on grabbing 'the onion.' you can follow me on tiktok, instagram, follow our accounts ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/27/2024 0:00am
... in peace. also married a blind, tribe called quest, my favorite rap group of all time, they and more and share are being honored at the rock and roll hall of fame. they once a week. michelangelo signorile, ben collins, congratulations on grabbing 'the onion.' you can follow me on tiktok, ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:59pm
... trump's old haunt. has been a rough week for donald. then he wanted all these protesters to show up. i'm telling you, i was there. there was one guy with a bell and a crucifix. ben, you have a cool name, even though it is only three letters. who won the week? well, i do want to say who ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:59pm
... i chose arexvy. rsv? make it arexvy. thank you jesus. we made it to the end of another week, which means it is time to play our favorite game. who won the week? with me, michelangelo and ben collins, you have a very full ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:54pm
... all of the writers have been let go and that is what we are going to do. it will be great. don't go anywhere. we are keeping michelangelo and ben to stick around and play our favorite game. you know what it is. who won the week is next. next. new bottles - _ ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:53pm
... i can be more sadistic than the others, i can help, if i can do this to dogs, can do this to a lot of people, maybe the people to want to count up and put in camps. it's horrifying. let's talk quickly before we move onto the next thing, ben. ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:52pm
... let's talk about another story. then, you are now the ceo of 'the onion.' we will pull up the new post. i'm kind of lucky i knew this was coming. i am a friend of ben. here it is. you guys used to post some hilarious pieces in the pre- ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/26/2024 11:47pm
... interested in saving democracy for our grandchildren? well, i don't think the election is over yet on that score. joining me now is michelangelo sig norelli, and ben collins, former nbc news ...
MSNBC: Ana Cabrera Reports
4/26/2024 2:03pm
... trump's defense inquiry of david pecker was over the arrangement that they had with him coming out of that august 2015 meeting, specifically as it pertained to stories about the clintons, but also the likes of ben carson, ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/25/2024 1:45pm
... blame ted cruz. he's yelling 'fake news' also because donald trump lied along with david pecker. they worked together to lie about ben carson, to lie about hillary clinton. fake news all around. i want to thank him for actually ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/25/2024 1:01pm
... stories in the 'national enquirer'. made up stories, made up the story about ted cruz's father, made up the lies about hillary clinton having six months to live, ted cruz's father, ben ...
MSNBC: Jose Diaz-Balart Reports
4/24/2024 3:48pm
... become a truth. and in this case, you saw story after story after story the effect it had. ben carson was doing surgery, leaving sponges in people's brains. and that's the sort of story that they were pushing while at the same time they were grabbing ...
MSNBC: Jose Diaz-Balart Reports
4/24/2024 3:47pm
... carson and he would send over, you know, some information, and david pecker said they would quote, unquote embellish it at the magazine and run a story but it was story after story after story on ben carson, on ted cruz and this relationship, you know, ...
MSNBC: Jose Diaz-Balart Reports
4/24/2024 3:46pm
... and it was incredible to hear just the details of this scheme. there was points, michael cohen was the point person in this, but there was -- pecker was describing phone calls where michael cohen would say, you know, put out a story on ben ...
MSNBC: Ana Cabrera Reports
4/24/2024 2:55pm
... rubio had a love child and used cocaine, ben carson allegedly leading a sponge in a patient's brain, a doctored photo suggesting senator ted cruz's father was involved in the kennedy assassination, all of those people who were targeted ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/24/2024 12:16pm
... 2016 campaign, and we are talking about ted cruz's father being involved in the jfk assassination, and there was a headline in the 'national enquirer' during that campaign, that dr. ben carson left a ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/24/2024 12:08pm
... cruz and ben carson. 'the enquirer' would embellish the stories, and pecker said he understood we to mean cohen and trump. ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/24/2024 10:09am
... about then-trump rivals and now allies senators ted cruz and marco rubio and ben carson. pecker said cohen would call and say, we'd like you to run an an article on a specific target. ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/24/2024 4:05am
... described that process. michael cohen would call me and say we would like you to run a negative article on ted cruz. he would send me information about ted cruz or ben carson or marco rubio. that was the basis of our story and we would embellish it from ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/24/2024 4:05am
... ben carson leading trump for the first time. and there was shocking claims, ted cruz caught cheating with five secret mistresses. that came out after polls ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/24/2024 4:04am
... ever they started to do well in the polls against trump. stories like bungling surgeon ben carson left sponge in patient's brain. that came after a poll showing ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/24/2024 1:05am
... sake on ted cruz. then he would send me information about ted cruz, ben carson, then we would embellish from there. prosecutor stein glass, you said michael cohen would call you periodically and say we ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/24/2024 1:04am
... inpatient's brain. i cannot right after a poll that showed ben carson leading trump for the first time. ben carson denies that allegation about the sponge by the way. then there were shocking claims, pervy ted cruz caught with ...
MSNBC: All In With Chris Hayes
4/24/2024 0:04am
... run a negative article, let's say for arguments sake on ted cruz. he would send me information about ted cruz or ben carson or marco rubio and that was the basis of our story. we would embellish it from there. michael cohen was not part of ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/23/2024 11:05pm
... communications director hope hicks in the room, was a win-win. the enquirer would publish negative stories about trump's opponents which they did repeatedly, particularly when ben carson, ted cruz, and marco rubio started rising in the polls in the spring of 2016. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/23/2024 8:07pm
... say do a story on this on ben carson and then they would embellish details in her own words. in their own words. and then em billish and a story would appear or ted cruz. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/23/2024 8:07pm
... what i found was really just -- i just couldn't believe it, just the explanation of how if michael cohen wants a story on ben carson, he would phone over to the 'national enquirer' and ...
MSNBC: Chris Jansing Reports
4/23/2024 6:18pm
... planted, michael cohen would call david pecker and he would have the germ of a story, say it's on ben carson, then it would be handed off to david pecker who would massage it and get it into the paper. but at one point, david pecker ...
MSNBC: Andrea Mitchell Reports
4/23/2024 4:25pm
... particularly donald trump was running against the likes of ben carson, but notably, ted cruz, and there's a series of 'national enquirer' pieces that were salacious and frankly unfounded in hurtful ones toward the likes of ted cruz. i was covering cruz's campaign ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 8:53pm
... when we go back to the republican primary in earlier 2016, there were stories the district attorney's office is prepared to present, stories that were also a part of this scheme against marco rubio, ben carson, ted cruz. what were those newsroom ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 8:15pm
... election all along through the 'national enquirer,' to bury stories about him, to accentuate his positives and write damaging stories about his rivals like ted cruz and ben carson. you played this portion of todd blanch's opening when he said, i have a spoiler alert. ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/22/2024 8:13pm
... the cover. and this is going to come out, too. we'll start hearing about the stories that caught and killed the stories that donald trump planted and the favorable ones about donald trump that he pushed forward. but he's had covers about ben ...
MSNBC: Trump on Trial New York v. Donald Trump
4/22/2024 5:36pm
... trump's opponents. for example, they mentioned ben carson who was running against donald trump and how they had a story in the 'national enquirer' that he was guilty of malpractice. there was negative stories about ted cruz. and then you get to another scene that was about karen ...
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show
4/21/2024 1:54am
... involved in stories that involved marco rubio. ted cruz. ben carson. hillary clinton. i don't quite know where that list ends. but i think we will hear a lot more about that relationship. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/20/2024 6:01pm
... we have ben following breaking news the last few minutes, all unfolding on capital held in a rare saturday session. the house has approved tens of billions in aid for ukraine. lawmakers waving ukraine's national flag on the house floor ...
MSNBC: Velshi
4/20/2024 3:17pm
... billion in foreign aid. if they pass, they will be packaged together and sent to the senate. the votes have ben long delayed because of republican drama and the drama is not over. the far right congressman from ...
MSNBC: The ReidOut
4/19/2024 11:25pm
... assaulted e. jean carroll. harry, let's get in on what the prosecutors are thinking now. they have to give the name of whoever that person is, and this is what ruth ben-ghiat, who ...
MSNBC: Jose Diaz-Balart Reports
4/19/2024 3:32pm
... i'll also just say on a separate note, in the last hour or so, the united states has imposed sanctions on an extremist israeli settler, his name is ben zhi, he's someone i actually met. ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/19/2024 2:59am
... any part in this tonight, i don't know that the u.s. would acknowledge it on the record. and i have to say i completely agree with what ben was wi explaining about the process here the israelis will, the source of strikes and they take in syria, remember the u.s. has ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/19/2024 2:55am
... about this one point we don't know about all the details, bo exactly how much fidelity the u.s. had on this but they were told by the israelis in advance. ben rhodes, how does that sound to you in terms of the procedure of israel notifying the united states today? in advanced of what happened ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/19/2024 2:50am
... role of wanting to avoid further escalation that could put israel at risk of itself. ben rhodes, you worked in the white house that had the best and strongest communication channels to iran of any white house since the fall of the shot, possibly, with ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/19/2024 2:44am
... although we are certainly trying to get more information to the public. i want to bring ben rhodes back into this discussion. from the perspective of inside the white house, of all the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/19/2024 2:38am
... and ben, what about the concept of proportional response? when israel is planning a strike like this, do they assess the damage that they suffered, which was minimal in this case, since the defenses were so effective against the iranian drones? ...
MSNBC: All In With Chris Hayes
4/18/2024 0:57am
... and, ben, just from the white house perspective and the biden perspective, i mean, it has been the day one stated objective of the biden administration to, like, stop regional escalation as, like, the most important thing, along with israel's defense after october 7th. where do you see their ...
MSNBC: All In With Chris Hayes
4/18/2024 0:54am
... her israeli democracy and the military. ben rocha served as deputy strategy adviser for national security for president obama, cohost of the podcast pensie the world, and they both join me now. let me start with you, because i've been reading your thoughts on this a lot, and have come to ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/17/2024 10:00am
... that's cooled some. it seems like a pure toss up. that's where we are, months until the election. semafor's ben smith, thank you very much, we appreciate it. talk to you again soon. thanks to all of you for getting up 'way too early' with us on ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/17/2024 10:00am
... a month or two ago, there was momentum in foreign capitals and the business world. that's cooled some. it seems like a pure toss up. that's where we are, months until the election. semafor's ben smith, thank you very much, we appreciate it. ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/17/2024 9:56am
... table. joining us now, editor and chief of semafor, ben smith. good to see you this morning. let's talk about these sanctions. what's the sense as to how effective they could be. these economic moves, could they deter, could they really put the squeeze on iran to make it think ...
MSNBC: Deadline White House
4/16/2024 8:29pm
... rubio and ben carson, stories about pretty much everybody. hillary clinton. and so that relationship at large, not just what ami's involvement is with stormy daniels, karen mcdougal, and ...
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show
4/16/2024 8:56am
... ben carner, hillary clinton. i don't quite know where that list ends, but i think we're going to hear a lot more about that relation sp. these guys have known each other for years. they both have very large estates down in palm beach and seem to go back a long time in ...
MSNBC: Inside With Jen Psaki
4/16/2024 7:50am
... not just about this one particular case. it's also about the media organization you used to work for pushing negative stories about a number of people who are trump's rivals. ted cruz, ben carson as well as a slew of negative stories about hillary clinton. ...
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show
4/16/2024 4:55am
... kills the stories of donald trump, stories that would never appear, the ones that we have heard a lot about, but also that he was somehow involved in stories that involved marco rubio, ted cruz, ben carson, hillary clinton. i don't know quite where that list ends, but i think we are ...
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show
4/16/2024 1:56am
... about, but also that he was involved in stories that involved marco rubio, ben cruz, hillary clinton. i don't know where that list ends, but i think we will hear a lot more about this relationship. these guys have known each other ...
MSNBC: Inside With Jen Psaki
4/16/2024 0:49am
... 2016 rivals, ted cruz, ben carson, hillary clinton. we remember these covers, many of us do. talk about how basically, you've touched on it a little bit, this entire organization was set up to protect a single candidate. ...
MSNBC: Trump on Trial New York v. Donald Trump
4/15/2024 2:38pm
... pointing to evidence that the prosecution wanted to present tied to negative stories about donald trump's primary rivals, including ben carson, marco rubio. folks may recall salacious headlines about alleged infidelity of ted cruz that the ...
MSNBC: Ayman
4/15/2024 4:14am
... october 7 it has been a pretty steady ratchet upward. that question will fall squarely on the shoulder of the prime minister as to whether or not he will retaliate for what happened last night. ben rose, always a pleasure. ...
MSNBC: Ayman
4/15/2024 4:07am
... joining me now political contributor ben rose who is a former deputy national security adviser. it's good to have you on the program. we know that biden officials are obviously worried about what an israeli response might be. some far right members of the government are calling for a ...
MSNBC: Ayman
4/15/2024 3:16am
... ukraine and domestic policy. jeremy ben-ami, thank you for your time. greatly appreciate it. next up, the other big story that will dominate this week. jury selection begins in the historic trial of donald trump's hush money criminal trial. and you know i didn't. ...
MSNBC: Ayman
4/15/2024 0:07am
... always a pressure. thank you for your explent reporting. take care -- excellent reporting. that i can care. now, ben, political advisory, ben good to have you with us. they are worry about what an ...
MSNBC: Ayman
4/14/2024 11:08pm
... or who are, you know, in ben's camp and they are so far right. a challenge. you can not really paint the whole political spectrum with one color. right. and that, i think, breeding some of the misunderstanding on the part of the americans. let me ask you, you brought ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/14/2024 6:14pm
... opening the door for some normalization of this kind of back-and-forth. i agree with ben, very concerning and on the other hand because of all the external pressures at play here and because the world knows ...
MSNBC: Inside With Jen Psaki
4/14/2024 4:12pm
... growing calls for conditioning aid. obviously some of the same diplomats are dealing with israel on a range of issues. ben roads who has spent time in the white house says it makes it harder to work on that and towards a deal. ...
MSNBC: MSNBC Breaking News
4/14/2024 3:12pm
... we learn from the war cabinet. ben, you mentioned, of course, the impact ongoing war between israel and hamas. help us understand what the impact of this back and forth between iran and israel has on that, how it impacts the u.s. ...
MSNBC: MSNBC Breaking News
4/14/2024 3:03pm
... correspondent raf sanchez and ben rhodes and john brennan. raf i will start with you. i know wiyou are busy reporting on the ground in tel aviv. give us a since what you witnessed and the feeling on the ground now. reporter: well, there was ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:52pm
... to do it. talk us through, richard, if you will, some of what we have seen from the proxies leading up to this moment. reporter: i think it was ben rhodes that you had on earlier and said the key to watch, is ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:42pm
... situation. ben was out mowing a number of ways this could go. the truth is no one knows exactly where it will go. both sides want to make sure that they do not appear week. ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:38pm
... ben, i want to bring you back into the conversation. the president has cut his weekend short in delaware and going back to the white house and meeting with his national security team. talk me through the conversation you are expected to have inside the white house right now. i think you have the ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:29pm
... ben rhodes, i want to bring you back into the conversation. i think tram mai brings up a good point. do you feel as if when you take a miscalculation and the killing of some of the top generals that a proxy attack ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:23pm
... and israeli air defenses end up meeting the challenge on all of the drones. i think it is really hard right now. aaron, standby. ben wrote standby. ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:16pm
... attack on israel but give me your top of mind thoughts at the moment. i think ben has it right. the iranians are looking for a way to navigate, perhaps, the action. it answers israeli strikes against senior commanders and ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:16pm
... iran surely understand his own abilities if the united states is pushed to the brink and must get involved as they said they will back israel until the end and warning the present and the sound that i play the saying, don't. don't attack. warning iran not to attack. i want to bring in -- ben, ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:11pm
... are verifying all the information that we get in before we report it. you think about the consequences of an attack like this and wanting to be incredibly careful with our reporting and the potential of what it could become. ben, with that news in mind, pick up on where you left off. we have seen ...
MSNBC: The Beat Weekend
4/13/2024 8:10pm
... i want to bring in former deputy national security adviser ben rhodes. he is a msnbc contributor as well. there is so many strengths to pull on with the scenario and what may be to come with a potential strike from iran on israel. ...
MSNBC: Alex Witt Reports
4/13/2024 5:33pm
... officer shot and killed the attacker. ben downey is on the scene. its been over four hours now since the man armed with a knife entered the shopping center here and killed six ...
MSNBC: Dateline
4/13/2024 9:15am
... as for the cause of julie's death, that was left in the county coroner's office. deputy coroner ben bradford. a very charred body. i could not very well identify it being a person. ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/12/2024 12:42pm
... that dartmouth could do better, but the way those professors stepped up and the president knew she had to do something. president julio frank at the university of miami has been a stalwart. ben sasse, you have seen these ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/12/2024 11:13am
... himself, you know -- david ben-gurion, the man, probably more than any other single human being created israel and allowed it to survive, when the war takes place in '67, a few months later he says, 'give back the ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/12/2024 11:01am
... there may be things dartmouth could do better, but the way the professors stepped up, the president, she knew she had to do something. president julio frank at the university of miami has been a stalwart. ben sasse at the university of florida. ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/11/2024 1:39pm
... that to delay the work in getting the bridge replaced. senator ben cardin of maryland, thank you very much for coming on. ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/11/2024 1:33pm
... capitol hill tuesday pleading for russia to free her husband. lawmakers joined her in demanding kara-murza's release. joining us is senator ben cardin of maryland. ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/11/2024 1:27pm
... they don't want to take orders from marjorie taylor greene. coming up next, it's been two years since russian opposition figure vladimir was imprisoned by vladimir putin. senator ben carden joins us next ...
MSNBC: Morning Joe
4/11/2024 12:59pm
... leading the charge on capitol hill to free a russian opposition figure jailed by vladimir putin. senator ben carden explains straight ahead on 'morning joe.' straight aheadn o'morning joe.'. morikawa on 18. ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/11/2024 9:51am
... mentioned, republicans there blocked an attempt to repeal that state's abortion ban. democratic senator mark kelly will weigh in on the fight for reproductive rights in his state. and democratic senator ben cardin of maryland will also ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 9:00am
... jared kushner not saying he's not going back into government service. ben rhodes, thank you again for your time. that is our show for tonight. 'way too early' with jonathan lemire is coming up next. the decision by the arizona ...
MSNBC: Way Too Early With Jonathan Lemire
4/10/2024 9:00am
... to be continued. jared kushner not saying he's not going back into government service. ben rhodes, thank you again for your time. that is our show for tonight. 'way too early' with jonathan lemire is coming up next. the decision by the arizona ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 8:56am
... this is ben rhodes, former deputy national security advisor under president obama and co-host of 'pod save the world.' ben, thank you for being here with me. as you look at it from a foreign policy perspective, how does ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 8:53am
... break. h ben rhodes after the break. what is cirkul? cirkul is the fuel you need to take flight. cirkul is the energy that gets you to the next level. cirkul is what you hope for when ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 8:51am
... hurt his son-in-law's business partner. it is all not a great look. we are going to talk about what kushner's foreign ties mean for trump and american foreign policy with ben rhodes after the ...
MSNBC: The Last Word With Lawrence ODonnell
4/10/2024 5:01am
... continued. ben rhodes, thank you my friend for your time. that is our show for tonight. now it is time for the last word with lawrence o'donnell. good evening. as with your hour, it is arizona night here at the last word. ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 5:00am
... the consulate in turkey. we will leave it there to be continued. ben rhodes, thank you my friend for your time. that is our show for tonight. now it is time for the last ...
MSNBC: Alex Wagner Tonight
4/10/2024 4:56am
... adviser under president obama, ben rhodes. thank you for being here with me. if you look at it from a foreign policy perspective, how does kushner's entanglement compromise potentially i don't know, the foreign policy platform of his father-in-law who is running to be the next ...